QUESTION: After viewing the latest data from Mars, I couldn't help but wonder why? Why are we repeating what Viking I and II had already found 20 years ago. After researching the data from these earlier missions I feel that we are wasting a lot of taxpayers money! ANSWER from Mark Adler on July 10, 1997: "Why" is always a good question. Actually Pathfinder and Sojourner are not repeating Viking. First and foremost, Pathfinder and Sojourner have shown that we can send spacecraft to Mars and explore the surface for $260 million dollars instead of the $3600 million dollars that Viking cost. So we are getting many times the bang for buck for the taxpayer, and will get even more bang for the buck in subsequent missions. In 1998 we'll be sending two spacecraft to Mars, an orbiter and a lander, for the price of one Pathfinder. Second, we are exploring a very different part of Mars with very different equipment than what Viking had. Pathfinder landed in a site that was (wisely) deemed too dangerous for Viking to land in. But Pathfinder's site is one that holds great interest in that it is an ancient flood plain into which very old rocks from the Martian highlands were carried. So the site acts as a window into a Martian past when there was liquid water on the surface and when life might have originated. Viking had no capability to examine the many rocks lying tantalizingly just out of reach, but the Sojourner rover can do just that. And Sojourner can do it with a sophisticated instrument that was not on Viking--the Alpha Proton X-Ray Spectrometer, which gives detailed elemental composition of the rocks. Furthermore, the IMP camera on the lander is far more capable than the Viking camera, and itself provides spectroscopic information on the surrounding terrain and rocks. Lastly, I'm not sure what you consider to be "a lot of taxpayer's money", but one interesting measure is to compute what fraction of the federal budget $260 million represents over three years, and from that, how much you contributed yourself to Pathfinder and Sojourner. It's about 60 millionths of what you payed each year for three years. For myself, that came out to about 25 cents a year for a grand total of 75 cents.